British troops continue to hurry along the Medellin to form a new defensive line. |
Spanish cavalry attempted to defeat the last formed French cavalry regiment and came close! They were pushed back leaving the French 26th dragoons unformed. |
With allied cavalry now firmly in control of the valley, Ruffin's division had no option but to form squares. Any thought of assaulting the Medellin would have to wait. |
Meanwhile on the Medellin, Stewart's brigade prepare to form a line at the top of the steep slope with Donkin in reserve behind. |
The Pajar redoubt is now back firmly in allied hands. |
In the centre more French infantry and artillery is brought forward to join the firing line. |
In Talavera, the Grenaderos Provinciales have been moved forward to defend the perimeter. |
To the north of Talavera, the two Polish battalions plunged into the Spanish line. The two Spanish battalions stood to receive the charges but both succumbed to the determined Poles. |
A Dutch battalion lead by Chasse now joins the Poles in driving in the Spanish (middle right). They charge and quickly overrun a Spanish 12pdr artillery battery. |
Both Polish battalions defeat two more Spanish battalions and here the 1/4th infantry maintain good order having resoundingly demolished the Provinciales de Guadix battalion. |
Milhaud's 3rd Brigade move towards the centre to replace Maubourg's division in reserve. |
The Spanish gain a respite from the two Polish battalions with one having to reform and the other (bottom left) failing to charge home against a battery of artillery. |
Three photos presenting an overview at the end of turn 13. At the top right Henestrosa attempts to extricate his cavalry from the morass of Spanish infantry swirling around him. |
Maubourg's cavalry division continue to arrive. |
With the final Dragoon brigade arriving the French are almost ready to commence another attempt at clearing the valley of allied cavalry. |
On the Cascajal Vilatte's division readies itself to advance on the Medellin. |
The French continue to struggle in the centre with one battery of artillery forced to retreat having suffered heavy casualties from British musketry. Two further batteries run low on ammo. |
The French are ordered to retire from the firefight before more damage is caused to them. |
As the French withdraw, the British use the lull to reorganise some of their battered units. |
The Spanish position is looking dire. The green dice indicate units that will have to take morale tests this turn (turn 14). |
The Dutch continue to sweep all before them. |
The Poles rout a Spanish unit when it charges it but the latter fails to put enough distance between them and are caught resulting in their destruction. |
Iglesias' division held in reserve, form attack columns in the hope of relieving pressure on the rest of the shaky Spanish army. |
Liger-Belair's French division sweep around the Pajar redoubt to reinforce Leval's attack. |
M. Zayas' brigade now breaks triggering a Spanish army morale test. Failure! The Spanish army now breaks and flees the battlefield. |
As Liger-Belair's division round the redoubt they are met by a murderous volley from the 40th line causing one battalion to falter. |
Oh dear, with the loss of the Spanish, the British are in a very precarious situation. However the Spanish did make a fist of it all things considered. As always a cracking game and loved the overview shot at the end of Turn 13, that really give you the sense of a large scale battle. Keep up the good work and lets hope for a miracle for the British. Maybe rain stops play;)?
ReplyDeleteMany thanks Steve. The British are certainly going to have to play hard to win this one!
DeleteThe Brits look horribly outnumbered and boxed in, unless nightfall is imminent it's hard to see why they would attempt to hang on rather than withdraw.
ReplyDeleteThe Spanish army collapsed so suddenly and competely - I'm guessing due to how the rules handle their morale rating, or was it a series of bad die rolls?
The Spanish do seem to have pretty much bucked the historical trend with infantry, frontally attacked in a strong position, yielding easily and their cavalry getting stuck in (they often seem to have departed early and without a fight). Again, is this dice or going with their ratings and the rules?
Many thanks for your comments Rob. The Spanish cavalry in particular did have very lucky dice rolls combined with the French being unlucky leading to some unusual outcomes! That said the Spanish cavalry did occasionally have their moments of glory such as the Rey Regt at Talavera, sadly not replicated here.
DeleteThe best of the Spanish infantry occupied the front line and did perform well albeit against disjointed French attacks. Once broken through to the soft underbelly it was only a matter of time before the Spanish broke. The problem for them really started as units broke leading to others doing likewise creating a cascade effect (in the rules the each unit breaking within 12cm is a -1 to morale and with the close proximity of many Spanish units made it hard for them to maintain control). They could have held on but a poor dice roll on the army test signalled their fate.
For the British, attempting a withdrawal with half the day left is probably more risky than trying to fight it out. Although heavily outnumbered (as they were historically without the Spanish), the two divisions of Sebastiani's corps attacking their right flank have suffered a mauling and are coming up against two fresh British brigades. The British centre is reasonably secure but the Medellin, starved of planned reinforcements, is not looking good. Their main hope is the cavalry win (highly unlikely) or the punishment dished out to the French as they scale the steep slopes is enough to drive them off.
If I had to give odds it would be 2:1 in favour of the French but still an interesting game to play out.
Thinking about it some more makes me wonder about the French. Historically they didn't touch the Spanish and their cavalry made no significant contribution. So, everything was concentrated against the British yet failed while this refight seems to heading towards overturning that result. Clearly something seems to have stopped them from overcommitting, but what was it? Any ideas? Were some commanders unwilling to see their, semi-independent, commands eviscerated if someone else (Joseph/Jourdan?) would reap the credit? Or was something else driving the need to keep a substantial reserve at all times as per… https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/bf/Battle_of_Talavera_final_attack.jpg
DeleteI think the French were over-confident believing their columns would defeat the British line with similar success experienced elsewhere. Only Ruffin was committed to the initial attack on the Medellin on the 28th with Joseph holding back his main attack until the Medellin had been taken. The heavy casualties suffered by the attack columns proved to be a shock for the French and they never really seemed to get around this problem throughout the Peninsular War.
DeleteWhat I have sought to do in my refight is to better co-ordinate the French attacks with two rather than one division tasked with taking the Medellin, and of course clearing the Spanish threat to the French left flank.
The French were clearly worried about Spanish forces threatening from the south and Soult was still a week away from arriving. Victor was pretty miffed that he could not make another attack on the Medellin on the 29th but it appears that the threat to Madrid was very much on the minds of the French commanders.
Thanks for the explanation, with one eye looking back at Madrid it's seems more reasonable that they would not want to get too entangled in pressing it to a conclusion.
DeleteExcellent write up - a very entertaining read. I am rooting for Joseph :-)
ReplyDeleteI like these games that does not have to finish in a few hours of play. Out of curiosity what rules are you loosing and how much time do you use on a turn.
Also, how do you like army morale tests - I have always disliked them. I can see that units near routing units test morale, but the concept of an entire army suddenly fleeing is not really that well nased in history....
Many thanks Sparta.
DeleteRules are General de Brigade by Dave Brown. I would guess about an hour on average per turn.
I am in two minds on Army morale tests. In my campaign if an army's morale collapses those formations still in good order and of good quality can act as a rearguard in certain circumstances. In this particular instance, it seemed plausible given the number of units breaking in a largely conscript poorly led army that morale would quickly evaporate. I know what you mean though and another advantage of solo play that you can easily adjust the rules to what you feel is right.
Splendid game Jon! A true feast for the eyes as usual. This game keeps mirroring ours with a few exceptions here and there. In our game (using Age of Eagles) it was Maubourg’s cavalry that broke the Spanish whilst the British cavalry were defeated on the left. Wellington’s infantry were caught in a vice and got badly mauled. Hard to see how the French got it wrong in real life.
ReplyDeleteMany thanks Mike. Not giving too much away before the next instalment but the French suffered a setback this morning! By no means a foregone conclusion in my game now and proving to be a fascinating refight.
DeleteAt a cursory glance over the Napoleonic French v' Brit games, the French appear to perform better than Historically. Any ideas as to what you would put that down too?
ReplyDeleteIf you mean my games then I have tended to find the French struggled against the British line as they did historically. If their columns can make it through the volleys of musketry reasonably intact then the British are normally on the back foot.
DeleteThe other way around, seems as if the french performed better than expected todate. Though looking at moves 17-24 it appears that they lose this one :-)
DeleteGood morning Jon
ReplyDeleteGreat report and imagery as usual. The British musketry holds on as usual.
Regards Peter
Splendid game so far. The Spanish side of things is particularly interesting. In set-up and after early french setbacks the masses of Spanish troops seemed impenetrable. But as it should be with Napoleonics, morale is more important than raw manpower. The other interesting thing is how the Pajar redoubt shapes the battlefield. It became an anchor for the new British flank.
ReplyDeleteMany thanks Pascal. The real shame is I painted up a bunch of Spanish units only for them to depart the battlefield without firing a shot!
DeleteIt seems that the plan to attack strongly on both flanks is paying off. I'll head to the final turns to see...
ReplyDeleteIt was at this stage.
Delete